Traditionally, many
advertisements released by cigarette brands under
the Philip Morris label have depicted happy people joined together in
friendship (supposedly due to their common habit). Other advertisements
attempted to associate cigarettes with sleek mystical figures, sometimes
even sexually desirable ones. All this has changed, however, due to
recent legal developments in which the cigarette giant was pressured to
offer anti-smoking ads, in addition to the usual fictional ones depicting happy mannequins.
In no way were they to advertise cigarettes, and they were mandated to help
stop youth smoking. These requirements placed Philip Morris in a difficult
situation. They needed to satisfy the courts, but at the same time also
make their advertisements as unsuccessful as possible. To the joy of Philip
Morris, Ogilvy explains that "the consumer perceives that the product is
inferior and never buys it again" (103). The product is of course not a cigarette,
in this case, but rather the message of the advertisement, "don't smoke".
Through the use
of dull visual features and two reversed advertising tactics, Philip Morris has successfully designed a
campaign certain to reach no one. The side benefit of positive PR for
the company, of course, was guaranteed regardless of the ad content.
The first goal of this article
is to attract as little attention as possible.
At first glance, the eye finds no special focus point. We
see two silhouettes seated at the far opposite ends of a small fishing boat out on a
motionless river. It looks more like a mournful life insurance advertisement than
anything else. The reader almost expects it to ask "Who will take care of your children?".
There are no bright colors, it contains a very mellow atmosphere, and there
is no movement.
Above the horizon is an uninteresting sky smeared with hazy white clouds. The
two tree-covered banks of the river converge in the distance far beyond the dingy as if
to immortalize the moment. This moment, as the reader discovers, is
one which should be anything but immortalized. Hidden up in the clouds is
a well-camouflaged light yellow box reading "HELP ME UNDERSTAND WHY SOME KIDS
YOUR AGE SMOKE CIGARETTES". As the eye continues to wander down towards the
darkened water between the dingy and the camera, one arrives at some text at
the bottom of the page just beyond the edge of the picture. At the right is
another yellow box similar to the one up in the clouds. This one contains
the text, "TALK TO YOUR KIDS ABOUT NOT SMOKING. THEY'LL LISTEN.". On the
left are two small paragraphs in plain font, containing
the quote "How to start the conversation [about smoking] is up to you". The
attention of the reader returns to the image, and once again sees nothing but a
bleak emotionless picture. Just to make sure the advertisement does not attract
any potential vacationers, the river is dotted with algae, and there is not a single
artificial structure in sight. In comparison to the dozens of other ads found
in magazines such as this one, nearly any reader would simply pass over it
without a second thought. For those who *do* play closer attention, however,
Philip Morris has carefully chosen visual queues to quickly send them on to the next page.
The ad plays on the need to escape,
but instead of showing a luxurious vacation
destination, it shows only an awkward social situation. "If dream and desire can
be exploited in the quest for sales, so can nightmare and fear" (Solomon, 56). Fowles
describes the need to escape as being "the freedom that every individual yearns for when
life becomes too oppressive" (72). To most people, a fishing
trip is synonymous with rest, relaxation, and enjoyment. For some, there is no better
way to spend some time away from the hustle and bustle of life than to break free and
head out to the lake for some fishing. Anticipating this crowd, Philip Morris made sure
to eliminate the yearning for a tranquil day on the lake. Rather than a beautiful fishing day,
the parental character in the advertisement is having a conversation with his daughter
about smoking. This is not exactly what a fishing trip is supposed to entail. The father
is stuck out in the middle of a river in a small boat, with nowhere to run and no foreseeable
end to a hair-raising conversation with his defiant daughter. These conversations are
of course notorious for being outstandingly uncomfortable for both the nervous parent
and the frustrated child. The parent must select just the right time, tone, and topic,
while the child tends to fidget throughout the whole conversation. One question about
a friends' drug use, and the child feels alienated. One misused word, and the conversation
may come to a dead stop. If the time is not right, the discussion may be doomed to start
with. The only escape is distraction or retreat. Oh wait, we're on a lake. So how about
those 'Niners?'.* By exploiting our need to escape, the ad leaves the reader feeling trapped
and anxiousm, eager to divert attention elsewhere.
In addition to the fear of lack of escape,
the ad also reminds the reader of
his/her responsibilities as a parent. Of all the tasks in the world, this is not one
which will draw crowds. Parenting is said to entail a list of extra-unpleasant tasks.
Among them are diaper changing, discipline, and "THE TALK". In no way, shape, or form
could this reminder possibly encourage parents to discuss nicotine use with their
children. Philip Morris has severely infringed on our need to escape. "Nobody in
their right mind wants to be intimidated, menaced, battered, poisoned... We want to
feel safe and secure; buy these products, advertisers are saying, and you'll be safer
than you are without them" (Fowles 72/73). Fowles' description, of course, is crafted for
an advertisement which is attempting to attract customers rather than repel them.
Nevertheless, the concept is identical. In normal ads, the viewer might be shown that without
product 'x', he/she will be caught in a socially awkward situation. Fowles lists a few
examples:
| As well as presenting positive images, advertisers can play to the need for affiliation in negative ways, by invoking the fear of rejection. If we don't use Scope, we'll have the "Ugh! Morning Breath" that causes male and female models to avert their faces. (Fowles 67) |
While most advertisements have
traditionally been designed with Murray's
fifteen appeals in mind, the Philip Morris corporation has turned them around
in order to minimize the effectiveness of their "good faith" anti-smoking
campaign. As we have seen, two of Fowles' needs were directly violated:
the "Need to escape" (72), and the "Need to feel safe" (72). Firstly,
the viewers' desires for freedom and socio-economic relief were shot down by fear of
being isolated on a boat, faced with the task of talking to one's offspring about
the effects of nicotine. Next, the reader was even more turned off when he/she
received the reminder that this awkward conversation was in fact their responsibility. The
viewer is left feeling frustrated, overwhelmed, and unhappy. What better solution
than to turn the page and gaze instead at a graceful Dorothy Hamill figure skater telling
them to purchase a wonderful mysterious product named Vioxx?